Thanksgiving Prep: Pies, Catering & Leftover Hacks

Thanksgiving might be about gratitude, but let’s be honest—it’s also about planning. From pies to catering trays and even what to do with all those leftovers, Fairfield County has you covered. 

Stamford–Bakeries & Cafés That Cover Every Craving 

Local bakeries are the secret weapon of Stamford hosts, offering everything from crusty breads to decadent desserts. DiMare Pastry Shop, a longtime favorite, is beloved for its pies, cookies and pastries that taste like tradition. For breads and parve goods, Beldotti’s is the go-to, ensuring your holiday table has the perfect balance of savory and sweet. Together, they make hosting—and gifting—a little more delicious.  

Greenwich–Caterers That Make Hosting Easy 

Planning a holiday gathering or fall get-together? Greenwich has some easy pick-up catering options that take the stress out of hosting. A Dash of Salt brings a personal, chef-driven touch to catering. Known for elevated seasonal menus and beautifully presented dishes, they’re a go-to for anyone looking to wow guests without lifting a finger. From intimate dinner parties to larger celebrations, they tailor menus to your occasion. Garelick & Herbs is a Fairfield County staple, loved for its gourmet prepared foods and stylish catering spreads. The offerings balance elegance and approachability—offering vibrant salads, artisanal sandwiches and refined entrées that taste as good as they look. 

New Canaan–Pies That Define Tradition 

A true local legend, Walter Stewart’s Market has been the place where generations of New Canaan families order their Thanksgiving pies. From pumpkin and pecan to classic apple, the offerings never disappoint. Picking up a pie here feels like taking part in a community tradition, one that guarantees your dessert table will be as nostalgic as it is delicious.  

Darien/Westport/GreenwichGourmet Made Effortless 

Aux Délices is the trifecta of gourmet prepared food, with locations across Darien, Westport and Greenwich. The Thanksgiving spreads manage to be both elegant and effortless, with seasonal sides, entrées, and desserts crafted for busy hosts who don’t want to sacrifice quality. Whether you’re gifting or gathering, Aux Délices ensures the holiday feels polished without the stress. 

Fairfield–The Pantry for Elevated Classics 

The Pantry has long been Fairfield’s go-to for elevated groceries and thoughtfully prepared dishes. The Thanksgiving catering menu reads like a dream: roasted vegetables, rich gravy, tender turkeys, and an array of pies to round it all out. Picking up from The Pantry is like having a trusted culinary partner—one that helps you create a holiday table that feels both abundant and refined. 

Weston–The Perfect Host Gift 

For a thoughtful and unique host gift, consider bringing both a fresh loaf from Baked in Weston and a sourdough starter to share—a hobby that’s taken off in recent years. This beloved microbakery in Weston is celebrated for its naturally leavened breads, sourdough bagels and other artisan creations. A gift from Baked in Weston offers not only something delicious to enjoy in the moment, but also the inspiration to bake and savor long after the gathering ends. 

Leftover Hacks: 

  • Transform mashed potatoes into crispy croquettes. 
  • Layer turkey, stuffing, and cranberry into next-day sandwiches. 
  • Stir pie slices into milkshakes for a decadent dessert remix. 
  • Place all your pre-orders early—by mid-November, many of these spots are fully booked. 

Related Articles

Inside Birch Bakehouse: The Old Greenwich Bakery Bringing Northern European Pastries to Town

above: Owner, Daina Olesen Latvian rolls, Swedish Princess cakes and...

Fresh on the Fork: New & Noteworthy Fall Dining

Right about now menus change, comfort food takes center...

Celebrity Chef Geoffrey Zakarian Launches Family Thanksgiving Can Drive with City Harvest

Geoffrey Zakarian is not only a celebrated restaurateur and...